We are GlacierPoint, the company that makes GlacierPoint Scan, so this is a vendor's comparison, and you should read it as one. We describe Purple Knight from Semperis' own pages and documentation, strengths first, and say plainly when it is the better choice. The comparison reflects both products in November 2026. Purple Knight changes with each release, so check semperis.com for current features and terms before you decide.

What is Purple Knight?

Purple Knight is a free, well-regarded and widely used identity security assessment tool from Semperis. It assesses Active Directory, Entra ID and Okta, with hybrid environments in mind. The current release as we write is Purple Knight 5.1, from August 2026.

You extract a zip file on a domain-joined Windows workstation or server and run PurpleKnight.exe. Semperis says the Active Directory scan needs no administrator permissions and makes no changes, and recommends not running it on a domain controller. Entra ID needs an app registration with read permissions in Microsoft Graph, created with a Semperis script by a Global Administrator; Okta needs an Okta administrator role. Semperis states that Purple Knight has no phone-home capability: results are written to an output folder on the computer that ran it, and only your organization has them.

The results are built on a published list of security indicators, each tagged as an indicator of exposure, of compromise, or both. The report gives an overall score, scores by category, every indicator's status and remediation guidance for each. Indicators map to MITRE ATT&CK, many also to MITRE D3FEND and some to ANSSI. Indicators of compromise look for signs of an attack, such as recent SIDHistory changes.

Purple Knight is a point-in-time assessment; for continuous monitoring, change tracking, alerting and remediation, Semperis sells Directory Services Protector. We found no published terms on running Purple Knight for clients as a paid service, so MSPs and consultants should check Semperis' current terms.

What is GlacierPoint Scan?

GlacierPoint Scan is a read-only assessment of Active Directory, Windows hosts and Microsoft 365. A portable Windows collector runs on a domain-joined computer under your own Windows account: no agents are installed, no domain passwords are requested and nothing is changed. It reads the directory, SYSVOL, AD Certificate Services, the computer it runs on and up to 100 remote hosts you choose. With a Global Reader sign-in, after a Global Administrator grants its read-only permissions once, it also reads Entra ID, Exchange Online, Purview, SharePoint, Teams and Defender.

The evidence is encrypted on the collecting computer and uploaded to the hosted portal, which evaluates it against 240 controls: 138 on premises and 102 for Microsoft 365, of which 40 are flagged for your own reviewer's judgment. You get a five-page executive brief for readers outside IT and a technical report with every finding and its evidence. An optional remediation plan builds unlinked GPOs for Active Directory, which you review and link yourself, and staged Microsoft 365 changes that record each previous value in a journal for a best-effort rollback, or export as a PowerShell script you run yourself. A verification rescan then shows what is in place. The first collection of an environment is free and fully evaluated, with the leading findings open; the reports and remediation unlock with a purchase. The user guide covers each step.

How do they compare?

 Purple KnightGlacierPoint Scan
ScopeActive Directory, Entra ID and OktaActive Directory, AD Certificate Services, Windows hosts and Microsoft 365
How it runsExecutable on a domain-joined Windows computer, no administrator rights for AD; an app registration for Entra IDPortable collector on a domain-joined Windows computer, as your account; Global Reader for Microsoft 365
Where results goAn output folder on the computer that ran it; no phone-homeEncrypted on the collecting computer, then uploaded to the hosted portal
OutputReport with an overall score, category scores and every indicator's statusFive-page executive brief and a technical report with per-host results
FrameworksIndicators of exposure and compromise mapped to MITRE ATT&CK, D3FEND and, for some, ANSSIControls drawn from Microsoft, CIS and CISA SCuBA guidance; no MITRE ATT&CK or ANSSI mapping
RemediationGuidance for each indicator; it makes no changesGuidance for each finding; optional plan of unlinked GPOs and staged Microsoft 365 changes you approve
Microsoft 365 workloadsNot covered beyond Entra IDEntra ID, Exchange Online, Purview, SharePoint, Teams and Defender
Windows hostsIndicators focused on domain controllers, such as SMBv1 and the Print SpoolerHost configuration of the collecting computer and up to 100 remote hosts
Cost modelFree; continuous monitoring is a separate Semperis productFirst collection free and fully evaluated; reports and remediation unlock with a purchase
Best forA free identity assessment across AD, Entra ID and Okta that stays on your networkOne assessment across AD, hosts and Microsoft 365, reported for two audiences

When is Purple Knight the better choice?

  • You want a free, quick identity score. Purple Knight is free, needs no administrator rights for Active Directory, and gives you scores to track between runs.
  • Results must not leave your network. Purple Knight keeps its results on the computer that ran it. Scan always sends its encrypted evidence to a hosted portal for evaluation, even when you collect offline and bring the file back. If your policy forbids that, Purple Knight fits and Scan does not.
  • You use Okta. Purple Knight assesses Okta; Scan does not.
  • You want an indicator framework. Purple Knight's indicators carry ATT&CK, D3FEND and ANSSI references and include indicators of compromise. Scan reports configuration against baselines, has no comparable mapping, and is newer, without Purple Knight's community track record.
  • You need depth in directory permissions and delegation. Purple Knight's published indicators include checks Scan does not have today, such as non-default principals with DCSync rights, AdminSDHolder permission changes, privileged SIDs in SIDHistory, trusts that weaken SID filtering, delegation to krbtgt or domain controllers, and shadow credentials.
  • Your domains are large. Scan's collector currently reads at most 200 users, 200 computers and 200 members per privileged group; above that, the account checks that depend on the inventory report the limit instead of a verdict.

When does Scan fit better?

  • You want one assessment across Active Directory, Windows hosts and Microsoft 365, including Exchange Online, SharePoint, Teams and Defender, collected in one run and reported together.
  • Someone outside IT has to act on the results. The executive brief says why each priority matters and what decision it asks for, next to the technical report.
  • You want help making the changes. Remediation builds unlinked GPOs and staged Microsoft 365 changes that you review and approve, with previous values recorded for a best-effort rollback.
  • You need to show the fix held. A verification rescan applies the same rules after the changes.

The limits above still apply: Scan is commercial after the free first collection, evaluates evidence in a hosted portal, and does not yet match Purple Knight's directory depth or its indicators of compromise.

Can you use both?

Yes. Many teams run a free tool for a quick score and a second one for depth or wider scope. Purple Knight gives a local identity score across Active Directory, Entra ID and Okta, with indicators that ask whether an attack has already happened. Scan adds host configuration and the Microsoft 365 workloads, a brief for leadership, and remediation with a verification rescan. Where both check the same setting, such as the krbtgt password age, two independent results are a useful cross-check. What is an Active Directory security assessment? covers what any assessment should check, and Scan vs PingCastle: which one fits you? compares Scan with the other widely used free tool.

Checked against

Read on November 11, 2026: